Expert's verdict: 7/10



?This product looks premium and the Loyd Grossman name adds to its quality image, especially as he doesn't endorse products often. The packaging is excellent, though a resealable pack may have added a nice twist. The nuts are lovely, though they are quite rich and indulgent so not something you would eat a lot of on your own. They are perfect for dinner parties, though. At this price they aren't an everyday option, but shoppers could justify the higher price tag.

Nigel Ashton, category controller, Nisa-Today's



Consumer's verdict: 8/10



?It's not easy to tell what the product is initially but the packaging is eye-catching and looks like a premium product. The smell and the taste was really good, especially the ones with the olive wedges. The bags are generous and have a good selection of nuts. The smell was overpowering at first, but not unpleasant. They would go well with drinks and I would serve them at a party. However, the sundried tomato ones smelt like a powdered soup mix. I would buy them again because the price is reasonable.

Ben Woozley, fireman, Lewes



A year down the line... Birds Eye Mediterraneo Company: Birds Eye Launch price: Vegetables £1.99 for 350g; fish £2.99 for 400g Today's price: the same Acid test verdict: 3/5





Birds Eye Mediterraneo was launched in June to increase interest and diversity in the frozen veg and fish sectors through its positioning as a range of authentic recipe dishes created by Mediterranean chefs. But the range has not "achieved sufficient scale to remain sustainable", a company spokeswoman said. In the light of this, it is under review, she added.