Unit sales to be axed by mad new EU law

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (2)
  • Save

It tried to ban pounds and ounces. It introduced rules on bendy fruit and veg.

Now, if controversial EU Food Labelling Regulations are approved, Europe will outlaw the sale of groceries using numbers - the oldest, most basic measurement of all.

Under the draft legislation, to come into force as early as next year, eggs by the dozen, a four-pack of apples, and eight rashers of bacon along with scores of other grocery goods would be banned as a description on packaging, after MEPs last week voted against an amendment to the regulations that would allow individual states to nominate products that can be sold by number.

Each country is currently allowed this exemption under existing EU food directives. But the new Food Labelling Regulations make no such provisions. And all groceries would have to be sold according to their weight instead costing the industry millions, and leading potentially to labelling chaos.

The legislation could even see special unit-based promotional packs offering ‘eight chocolate bars for the price of six’ banned.

The legislation was declared “bonkers” and “absolute madness” by food industry experts, and although the implications of the draft were likely to have been an oversight, according to Federation of Bakers director Gordon Polson, it may be too late to change.

“The problem is now the exemption has been omitted from the legislation, it will be very difficult to get it put back in,” said Polson.

When food industry lobbyists tried to rectify the omission with an amendment, after it was discovered in the 174 pages of amendments to the initial 75-page proposal, there was not enough time to convince members of its importance before the crucial vote, he added.

“This is hindering rather than helping the consumer, taking away one of the key bits of information,” said a major supplier. “If this goes through it would demonstrate how far removed the legislators are from the real world. It’s bonkers.”

Another industry source added: “It’s absolute madness. You can’t make any argument that consumers are being confused by labels for six eggs or four bread rolls.”

Egg manufacturers would be particularly affected, added a BRC spokesman. “The egg industry has not been following these regulations closely and will get a shock. Each egg box would have to be weighed individually.”

But with a second reading still to come, the BRC spokesman added: “There is still time for this to be changed. We are pushing hard.”

An instant guide to the EU’s new-look label guidelines
Now: 24 Weetabix
What the label must say: 454g of Weetabix

Now: 6 sliced white rolls
What the label must say: 322g of sliced white rolls

Now: Half a dozen medium eggs
What the label must say: 372g of eggs

Now: 8 fresh thick sausages
What the label must say: 454g of fresh thick sausages

Read more

Editor’s Comment: The EU’s attempt to simplify labelling has created a multi-headed monster(26 June 2010)

Readers' comments (2)

  • From the POV as a consumer, I will find this useful.
    An example - my local supermarket sells a pack of 8 apples for £2. I can also buy them per kg for £1.69. How do I work out the best value? I have to weigh the 8 pack and then try and work it out.

    I am under the suspicion (as are many consumers) that we are being fiddled in many ways - pack amounts (e.g 4 pack, 8 pack) stay the same, but produce size goes down. But price remains the same.

    As for the egg industry suffering: I am sure they will pass on the cost of weighing each item to the consumer anyway.

    Selling things in packs is of benefit to the seller: I am not convinced there is much benefit for the consumer.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Another ill conceived example of EU food labelling regulations intending to make things easier but having the opposite effect.  A 'one size fits all' approach cannot work for the consumer across all food categories.  Recipes call for a number of large eggs rather than an amount in grammes and when buying a filling for sandwiches you want to know how many slices of ham in the pack.  
    I'm not condoning the French but you have to quietly admire them.  If they disagree with an EU law  they just chose to ignore it, whereas in the UK we blindly follow and enforce it no matter how ludicrous it may be.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

You must sign in to make a comment

Related images

  • Print
  • Share
  • Comments (2)
  • Save

Grocer jobs Experts in FMCG

Search jobs



CLICK HERE to search for the products, services and companies you need in the definitive guide to the UK food and drink industry.


The Grocer's commentators and opinion makers