
Pre-budget cost of living measures to remove tariffs on everyday food items have been dismissed by experts as ineffective, and will have a “limited impact on prices”.
The government last Friday confirmed it would press ahead with already-maligned proposals – first put forward by former Chancellor Rachel Reeves in May – to remove tariffs from more than 100 everyday food items.
The move forms part of a raft of “everyday fixes” by PM Andy Burnham and Chancellor John Healey designed to ease pressure on household budgets. It follows an industry consultation, and includes products ranging from garlic to gherkins, marmalade, boiled sweets and chocolate-based products, while tariffs would also be removed from imported kerosene and fertilisers.
Together with an earlier tariff reduction initiative unveiled in the spring, covering products including pasta, fruit juice and tuna, the two packages were expected to reduce consumer costs by between £245m and £595m a year, the Treasury claimed.
But with the total estimated savings for a household put at only £21 per year per, or just 40p per week, the government’s claim that its measures would “make a difference” to rising inflationary pressures has faced short shrift from the Food & Drink Federation.
The FDF had been a key critic of the original tariff cut announcement – alongside the contention it would ease the cost of living – back in May.
Analysis shared by the industry body with The Grocer in June suggested that 92% of the products from the first tariff package already entered the UK tariff-free due to existing trade agreements. Many more in the second tranche of tariff removals confirmed on Friday would also enter the UK tariff-free, the FDF said at the time.
As a result, it warned these tariff-free imported foods could effectively undercut UK-produced foods, in messaging repeated by FDF director of sustainability and growth Balwinder Dhoot this week.
“We are concerned about removing tariffs on finished food and drink products that are manufactured here in the UK. Doing this would have a limited impact on prices, while hitting British businesses and jobs,” he said, while reiterating the FDF’s call for tariffs to instead be removed from ingredients.
“Food manufacturers are committed to keeping costs as low as they can for consumers and removing tariffs from key ingredients can help with this. It’s more expensive to make food and drink here in the UK than in many of our close neighbours, as businesses face such high energy costs,” Dhoot added.
“If government wants to help UK shoppers and protect jobs, they would be better off looking at bringing down these costs, for example by extending existing energy relief to include food and drink manufacturing.”
The tariff package and the government’s wider pre-budget announcements “can make a real difference – not just in managing today’s costs, but in helping families look ahead with greater confidence and optimism”, claimed business secretary Jonathan Reynolds.
However, NFU president Tom Bradshaw was similarly sceptical of the package’s effectiveness in reducing inflationary pressures.
He questioned whether a fertiliser tariff cut would make “a meaningful difference” to farm businesses or household food bills, despite Defra secretary Angela Eagle stressing it would “help ease the pressure on farmers while opening up more choice and supporting food production here at home”.
While it was “right our government looks to strengthen its resilience by reducing tariffs on imported fertiliser, in reality much already comes to the UK tariff free”, Bradshaw noted.
“Any impact at farm level will depend hugely on whether the products covered are those UK farmers use and whether those reductions are passed through the supply chain,” he added. “Much bigger factors are driving fertiliser costs – as we have said repeatedly, strengthening domestic food production is the best way to improve food security and cost of living pressures.”
The government “still has time to back British farming and our food producers in tomorrow’s budget”, Bradshaw insisted.
“It can ensure the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism does not disadvantage domestic producers by increasing fertiliser costs; it can widen the Annual Investment Allowance scope to support infrastructure such as reservoirs and it can reverse changes to Agricultural Property Relief and Business Property Relief.”
Others to have criticised the tariff removal plan include Anna Taylor, executive director of the Food Foundation, who said the announcement “falls short of what families across the country were hoping for as they continue to struggle with high food prices”.
Families facing cost of living pressures needed “meaningful support to put nutritious food on the table, not marginal savings on unhealthy products”, she added, while reiterating calls from last week to extend the Healthy Start scheme to all pregnant women and children under five in low-income families.
The trio’s interventions come ahead of tomorrow’s budget, where the Chancellor is expected to unveil a far more consequential anti-inflation measure in the form of an extension to the fuel duty freeze, according to numerous media reports today.






No comments yet