A good naan should be crisp on the outside, soft inside, and pleasantly yet subtly seasoned. Sainsbury's (one star) tried a different approach, with a soggy and artificial offering. It didn't work.

The Morrisons (two stars) effort was slightly better. Though still damp, the bread had a pleasant, slightly spiced, taste.

(three stars) concentrated on looks with an appetising naan, but its great appearance and crisp texture was let down by its blandness. Tesco's (three stars) bread had a similar failing. Its decent texture couldn't make up for its lack of taste.

Asda's (four stars) bread won the day. Though a little too floury, this naan was well-seasoned, had great dough and crisped up nicely.