morrisons sign store

Morrisons is facing a backlash from suppliers after revealing plans for a “depot rejection charge” which would see the supermarket introduce new penalties from January.

The Grocer has learnt the retailer has notified suppliers it will charge £10 for every case, tray or out-of-box unit rejected at its depots, capped at £750 per SKU, per delivery.

However, angry suppliers have complained that the scope of the system is unclear and that it does not allow for a proper disputes process.

They have also warned that Morrisons’ new practice could become a “template” for other retailers and wholesalers.

The new fines will apply to all products across the Morrisons range and covers quality issues, damage, short shelf life, and failure to meet agreed specifications.

However, supplier sources told The Grocer it followed an increase in rejection levels over the past year, and many claimed these were for reasons outside their control or out of proportion to the fault.

A source told the Grocer: “Depots currently operate with widely differing levels of receipt accuracy, as well as numbers of claims and rejections, giving rise to the concern that the interpretation will not be uniformly applied.

“Many are concerned it could become a template for other retailers and wholesalers.”

It’s understood there have been examples including a full pallet of more than 100 cases being turned away by Morrisons for having two crushed boxes, with particular depots being identified as the “worst offenders”. Morrisons is also facing claims that the exact terms of the fines are unclear. “Suppliers do not know whether a broken pallet or loose wrap, with intact product, counts as a chargeable rejection,” added the source.

“It’s unclear whether one bad pallet means a whole load is rejected and charged.” There are also fears over how late amendments to orders for the supermarket arrive after suppliers’ system cut-offs, so the changes cannot be actioned.

“There are examples of loads that miss a booking slot being rejected even though there is no quality issue. There is also inconsistency between depots, including between depots run by Morrisons and by third-party operators,” said the source.

They added: “Suppliers’ biggest concern is that they cannot see, check or challenge rejections in time. Rejection reasons and photos sometimes arrive days later, by which time stock may have moved several times.

“Morrisons’ letter does not explain what evidence is needed to dispute a charge, the deadlines, or what counts as a valid dispute.”

Whilst there is anger over the new fines, suppliers have been advised that there is no ground to challenge it under the Groceries Supply Code of Practice (GSCOP), and “the fight is over how it is applied”.

But the source added: “Suppliers fear the charge will spread if it becomes a source of income rather than a quality lever.

“Tesco is reported to already apply a similar charge on ambient deliveries, and suppliers say foodservice wholesalers have approached them with similar schemes.

“Some cited Denmark, where retailer penalty regimes are seen as an established part of the business model.”

Whilst some see it as a genuine attempt to improve inbound quality, others call it “a land grab, not a cash grab”. The common worry is individual depots treating it as a local income stream.

Morrisons told The Grocer it was fully consulting with suppliers over the new system of fines, describing them as “balanced and proportionate”.

“Our customers rightly expect the products they buy from us to be of good quality and this starts with the delivery of products from our suppliers.

“This new way of working will help ensure that together we meet those standards, every time.  

“Where suppliers deliver stock in line with our agreed terms, no charges will apply. As with the introduction of any new ways of working, we understand that suppliers may have questions and we will shortly be providing them with a detailed FAQ which we are confident will allay any concerns.

“We are committed to working collaboratively with our suppliers with the aim of providing the best quality and value to our customers when they shop with Morrisons.”