Copy of Sugar web

Nesta found that under the government’s plan, 73% of food products would require detailed ingedient-level data to calculate levels of free sugars

A new report by a body of influential government health advisers has urged ministers to simplify plans for a new nutrient profiling model, to end a deadlock threatening to derail the government’s fight against obesity.

Plans to update the two-decades-old 2004 NPM, with a new model devised by experts in 2018, have become bogged down in a huge row with the food industry, with claims it would see thousands of products reclassified as HFSS.

Research from Oxford Economics has claimed that the tougher new rules required on calculating free sugars in the model could contribute to costs of nearly £3,000 per product for companies to adapt – 50 times the estimated cost in the government’s official estimate.

However, this week a report by Nesta, which has been heavily involved in helping the government draw up its obesity strategy, urges ministers to make significant changes to the model. It claims doing so would hugely reduce the cost of administration without significantly affecting the health outcomes.

Nesta’s research found that under the government’s plan, almost three-quarters of food products (73%) would require detailed ingredient-level data to calculate levels of free sugars.

However, it claims the vast majority of the extra effort required made “little difference” to the health or regulatory outcomes.

It found among the products required to carry out extensive work to calculate free sugar levels, only around 500 – just 4% of the supermarket products the study covered – could see this effect whether or not they were classed as HFSS under advertising and promotions rules. 

Fewer than 1% of products moved between “healthier” and “less healthy” under any assumption tested.

Nesta examined free sugar content in more than 11,000 products, using the information printed on the back of the product’s pack.

It found that the easiest free sugar levels to calculate were for products such as soft drinks, juices and smoothies and the vast bulk of sweets and confectionery.

Far more difficult to calculate were products such as ice cream, yoghurts and desserts.

However, Nesta said a raft of products including soups, sandwiches and ready meals would face complex tasks to quantify free sugars, despite their low impact on sugar intake.

The research found the 10 most complex categories together accounted for less than 5% of children’s free sugars intake.

Nesta said it was vital that implementing the new NPM should not hold up the government moving forward with its plans – which also include a healthy food standard, including mandatory reporting and targets on the healthiness of their sales. Nesta claims the plans could help around three million people achieve a healthier weight.

With the NPM a crucial component of that scheme, Nesta said changing the model was a solution to the current stalemate threats to derail the government’s plans.

“Attempting to calculate free sugars and NPM 2018 scores with a uniformly high precision across all categories could mean investing a lot of effort into assessing products that make little difference to public health, rather than prioritising the top contributors to population free sugars intake,” the report states.

“The immediate focus should be on determining, with certainty, whether products covered by the HFSS regulations are ‘healthier’ or ‘less healthy’.”

Nesta recommends that for the first year of mandatory reporting only the sales-weighted average NPM 2018 scores should need to be reported, with outstanding issues given longer timelines for resolution.

“Our analysis shows that we need not and should not wait until we have achieved high precision on everything before we start doing anything,” said Annie Denny, director of healthy life at Nesta.

“Implementing the changes required for the updated nutrient profiling model is no easy task for industry, but our analysis does suggest it is possible.

“Crucially, in our analysis, only around one in 25 products was hard to classify as ‘healthier’ or ‘less healthy’ and a couple of simple changes to government’s technical guidance could cut the work involved.

“There should be a path forward for government and industry to work together on pragmatic solutions to simplify free sugars calculation.

“Everyone involved wants the same thing – for healthier food to be the easier option. The healthy food standard, which would level the field and bring in mandatory healthiness reporting and targets for supermarkets, is how we get there.

“The free sugars work is important, but it needn’t slow this down, so we’d encourage everyone to keep moving on the healthy food standard alongside it.”